Honestly, Amir has worked very hard but violence doesnt suit his persona... the movie is full of funny witty scenes but in flash backs... rest of it is all about his revenge and short term memory ... which even the villain makes fun off.
Music is hummable... Asin looks good n acts gud ... but isnt she doing the repetitive of the south version ? so is the bad guy ... rest Jiah ... wasted!
Extra hype created for marketing gimmicks, Of course Amir's worth it ...but not the movie... its not the biggest hit of the year...but it would, should do well for Amir's sake.
I prefer Shah Rukh's Rab Ne..... !