I have no idea, if it is true, why there have been mixed responses. I guess that is always true to a movie and a custom to a movie release.
I am a Shah Rukh fan, but even for any non-Shah Rukh fan, your respect will only go up after this movie, and this new girl WATCH OUT FOR HER...she is a pocket house of talent.
Beautiful songs, beautifully picturized, Shah Rukh Khan playing an insecure too "boring" ordinary guy for this hype girl who falls in love and love can make you do things you never expect. And it shows that you confidence comes with appearance, and you appear how you feel :)

LOVED IT,,,,,,,,2 thumbs up (if i had more thumbs, i would add :)

I remember coming out of Om Shanti Om and hating it, But for me this movie is one of my Shah Rukh's favorite.
Lets believe it, "Bollywood" is an escape for most of ur desi, as @ the same time i am the biggest fan for artistic cinema of Gulzar, Mira Nair, Basu Bhattachariya, Shyam Benegal, etc.,,, i do enjoy commercial fun, as long as its good, and there is some "entertainement" which clearly Yuvraaj lacked....