5 Excellent

Dev D is different but not boring. Some of the dialogues are gem because they come out of nowhere - ticket kha gaya - and remind one of Pulp fiction.

Mr Taran Adarsh, you will gain some respect if you accepted that you got it wrong on this one. I remember the last time you got it so wrong was when you panned Bunty and Bubly and then spent weeks trying to proclaim a super hit as an average average success. You seem to be now justifying your conclusion again against the data judging by the nature and length of your box office commentary on this one.