- The immaculate detailing in recreating the 1960s Mumbai - Few bright moments - Ranbir Kapoor as Johny Balraj - Kay Kay Menon
What could have been better:
- There's nothing new in the story or the script. Umpteen times you get
the feeling 'I have seen this before'. - Trying to create the magic of Godfather, but failing to do so - Karan Johar (better stick to production and direction!)
What fails miserably: - More attention to the 'velvet' than to the soul of the story!